Amazon is selling Oreo Reese’s Peanut Buttery Creme Chocolate Sandwich Cookies for $4.xx via Sub & Save with free shipping for Prime members. That’s a solid 10% savings off the regular price of $4.xx.

Why This Deal Is Worth Grabbing

If you’re a fan of Oreo’s limited-edition and rotating flavors, this Reese’s Peanut Buttery Creme variety blends the iconic chocolate cookie with creamy peanut butter filling—a natural pairing for anyone who enjoys the classic combo. These are perfect for snacking straight out of the box, dunking in milk, or crumbling into desserts and ice cream.

The Sub & Save subscription discount removes friction from repeat purchases. If you enjoy these cookies regularly, setting up a recurring delivery means you’ll lock in this price without having to remember to reorder each time.

How to Get This Deal at Amazon

  1. Tap the SHOP HERE button above to open the product page at Amazon.
  2. Select the Sub & Save option at checkout to activate the $4.xx price (non-subscribers see the regular price).
  3. Complete your order to lock in free shipping with Prime and confirm delivery timing.

Smart Buying & Price Context

At $4.xx, this price sits 10% below the regular retail price of $5, making it a reasonable entry point for specialty cookie flavors that often hold steady or move upward seasonally. Amazon’s Sub & Save program typically adjusts discounts based on category and volume, so locking in this rate now protects you from future bumps if you plan to reorder.

If you’re unsure about the flavor, buying one box through this deal lets you test it without overspending before committing to a subscription.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Sub & Save and how does it work?

Sub & Save is Amazon’s subscription service for pantry staples and snacks. You choose a delivery frequency (every 1–6 months), and Amazon applies a discount to your recurring order. You can cancel or modify your subscription anytime without penalty, making it a low-risk way to lock in savings on items you buy regularly.

If you’re not a Prime member, standard shipping costs will be added at checkout. Prime membership also qualifies you for other perks like faster standard delivery on most items.

Can I cancel my subscription after the first order?

Yes. Amazon’s Sub & Save subscriptions are flexible—you can cancel immediately after placing your first order, or modify the delivery schedule to skip shipments. There are no long-term contracts or cancellation fees.

This Oreo Reese’s deal offers solid value for specialty cookie lovers, and the Sub & Save flexibility means you’re never locked in. Browse more Amazon food and grocery deals to find other items on sale this week.

Join our WhatsApp channel for kids’ deals, fashion deals, and other crazy deals.

Download our mobile app for hot deal notifications.

🚚 Fast & Free Delivery

Want Free Same-Day / 1-Day Delivery on this deal?

Start a 30-Day Amazon Prime Free Trial — cancel anytime, keep the free shipping & member-only deals while it lasts.

Try Prime 30 Days Free →
✓ Zero Upfront Cost · Cancel Anytime
Bonus Perk: 30-Day Audible Free Trial Get 1–2 free bestselling audiobooks to keep forever ($0.00 cost · cancel anytime).
Get Free Audiobooks →
🎓 College Student? Get 6 Months Free →
💳 EBT / Medicaid / SNAP? Get 50% Off ($6.99/mo) →
DealsFinders participates in the Amazon Associates program and may earn a commission or bounty from qualifying sign-ups at no cost to you.
Visited 1 times, 1 visit(s) today
Share this deal
Follow Us
Was this deal helpful?

Want more deals like this?

Follow it and we will tell you when we post a new deal for it. No account needed.

DealsFinders Newsletter

Pssst... want to join the newsletter?

Join 2,600+ deal-hunters — be the first to know about exclusive deals, insider promos, and exciting freebies!

● Live Community Verification
Looking for more discounts from Amazon?
View All Amazon Coupons →